Yes. In most migrations your product reviews can move to Shopify, usually into a reviews app such as Judge.me, where they are matched to the right products by SKU. How they get there depends on your current platform. Some platforms have a clean review export, some need the database or an API, and a few have no export at all.

How reviews get onto Shopify

Shopify has no built-in place for imported reviews, so they go into a reviews app. On AmeriCommerce, for example, reviews move into Judge.me or your chosen app, matched on SKU. Native reviews are not one of the seven core exports there, so we confirm the extraction route in the audit.1 Drupal Commerce reviews move the same way, whether they are stored as comments or in a review module.2

On self-hosted platforms, the database fills in what the exports leave out. X-Cart’s export page includes reviews only with the Product Reviews add-on, so we read anything the exports miss directly from the MySQL database.3 The matching key matters too. On ePages, for instance, the ePages product number becomes the SKU and serves as the join key for redirects and reviews.4

When your platform has no review export

Even without an export, some reviews can still be saved. When SoSlanty moved from Weebly, Weebly support confirmed there is no review export. The 110 store reviews existed only as HTML on the home page, so we captured them from the rendered site and imported them into Judge.me; this required a placeholder email for each reviewer, and the dates could only be approximated.5 The product reviews existed only in the owner’s records, so she typed them into a spreadsheet template we supplied. After de-duplication, 112 remained, and they went in on go-live day against 89 products.5 We consider that review rescue the best-value work in the project.5

What can drop out or change on the way

On projects like this, a few details typically affect the final count:

  • Reviews with a star rating but no written text cannot be imported into the reviews app we usually use, so we tell you up front what will be dropped.6
  • Your old platform’s review count may be wrong. On BigCommerce, review counters often over-report because deleted reviews are never subtracted, so we count the reviews themselves.6
  • Dates need checking. Imported dates are read as day/month, so they are worth checking in the preview.6
  • Moderation carries over. Hidden or disapproved reviews come across still hidden, and we ask you to confirm your moderation choices, since US rules restrict selectively suppressing negative reviews.6

Once your reviews are in an app, they stay put. Reviews held in a review app live in the app, not the theme, so a later redesign does not affect them.6

What reviews cannot do

Imported reviews cannot become Google reviews. A Google review exists only when the customer writes it from their own Google account, and there is no import, API or partner program that writes reviews into a Business Profile.7 Your migrated product reviews can still count on Google in two ways. They can power stars on product pages through product review markup, which we set up from your product reviews.7 They can also feed Google store ratings if they are collected on an approved platform, though Google needs 100 reviews in the last 12 months in your country and a 3.5 average before the stars show.7

For your own store, the answer comes down to four things: where your reviews live today (built into the platform or in a separate review app), whether an export, API or database copy exists, how many are star-only, and which Shopify reviews app you want them in. The pre-migration audit checks all four.

Sources

  1. AmeriCommerce to Shopify Migration Guide (2026) Migration guide
  2. Drupal Commerce to Shopify Migration Guide (2026) Migration guide
  3. X-Cart to Shopify Migration Guide (2026): Cost & Steps Migration guide
  4. ePages to Shopify Migration Guide (2026): Cost & Steps Migration guide
  5. Weebly to Shopify Migration Case Study: SoSlanty (2026) Case study
  6. Reviews From our project notes
  7. Google Review Management for Shopify Stores Page

“From our project notes” are short, anonymised lessons from migrations we have run. They describe what we typically see, not a guarantee for every store.

Want it answered for your store?

Tell us about your store in ten minutes. We come back within one business day with an honest assessment, a recommended track and a fixed price.