
By Lance Allison, Founder of Ruby Digital Agency | October 2026 | ~25 min read
If you have ever put a K-series into a car that never came with one, bolted a J-series V6 to a gearbox it was never paired with, or asked an S2000 engine to make far more power than Honda designed it for, there is a good chance something from inlinePRO is holding it together. They make the head stud sets that stop a turbocharged L15 in a late-model Civic, a K20C4 in an Accord 2.0T or a built K24 from lifting its head; connecting rods for H22 and B-series builds; cylinder head packages machined to the stage you choose on your own core; Signature Series short blocks; and race-spec timing chain tensioners for the S2000. It is the kind of catalog where every part exists because somebody broke the one before it.
The swap hardware is where it gets clever. The J-series adapter plates mate Honda’s V6 to other gearboxes, including the CD009 six-speed from Nissan’s 350Z; the S2000 transmission conversion kit does the same job for the F20C and F22C; there are adapter plates for layouts as far apart as K-to-F and BMW E36 and E46 gearboxes; and the S2000 rear diff conversion lets the car keep a stronger differential behind all that new power. Add turbo kits, MLS head gaskets, fuel rails and a core program for parts built on your own engine. If you are building a Honda and have not looked at their head studs, start there: the store’s best sellers since launch are almost all stud sets, and the people who buy them come back for the next car.
The difficult part of this project was not the engineering in the catalog. It was moving more than eight years of online selling from BigCommerce to Shopify without breaking the thing that matters most in a parts business: the price a customer sees for the exact configuration they choose. inlinePRO sells cylinder head packages in stages, stud kits in sizes and alloys, and conversion kits with and without components, and on BigCommerce most of those prices lived in option rules. This is the story of that move, with the numbers, the one finding that changed how we priced the whole store, and the first six weeks on Shopify, measured honestly.
The short version: inlinePRO had been selling on BigCommerce since at least February 2018, the date of the first order in its records. We moved it to Shopify in 26 days from kickoff to go-live, and the data itself, every product, customer and order, was imported and verified in the first two of them. The store moved 267 products and 409 priced option combinations, 1,686 customers with their marketing consent, 1,419 orders worth $824,684 with their original order numbers, 55 collections and 320 redirects, with zero failed records and zero emails sent to customers by the import. The storefront runs on Shopify’s Horizon theme with no custom theme files at all. It went live on August 20, 2026, its very first order was paid with Shop Pay Installments, and September, its first full month, brought more orders than any September since the store opened online. The whole migration ran on our own AI-driven migration technology, with a person checking every category of data against the source before launch.
For anyone arriving from a search: a BigCommerce to Shopify migration is the process of moving an online store’s products, option pricing, customers, order history, URLs and integrations from BigCommerce to Shopify, then rebuilding the storefront on a Shopify theme, because themes never transfer between the two platforms. This BigCommerce to Shopify migration case study documents one such move end to end, with every figure taken from the project files and the store’s own Shopify data rather than from memory.
In This Article
- The Client: Honda Race-Engine Hardware, Racing Since 1995
- What We Found When We Looked Under BigCommerce
- The Pricing Trap: 295 of 409 Option Prices Wrong in the Platform’s Own API
- 1,419 Orders With Their Original Numbers, 1,686 Customers With Their Consent
- Collections, Clean URLs and 320 Tested Redirects
- A Horizon Storefront With No Custom Theme Code
- The First Six Weeks on Shopify, in Numbers
- What This BigCommerce to Shopify Migration Case Study Teaches
- A Quick Overview of Ruby Digital Agency
- A Ten-Step Plan for Your Own BigCommerce to Shopify Migration
- What Happens If You Do Nothing
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Final Thoughts
Key Takeaways
- inlinePRO moved 267 products, 409 priced option combinations, 1,686 customers, 1,419 orders worth $824,684 and 320 redirects from BigCommerce to Shopify with zero failed records, in 26 days from kickoff to go-live on August 20, 2026.
- The data migration itself took two days, because our own AI-driven migration technology imported each category of data and reconciled it against the source in the same working session.
- BigCommerce’s APIs reported the wrong price for 295 of the store’s 409 option combinations, by between $20 and $1,800, and missed whole option branches. Every price on the new store was taken from what the live BigCommerce storefront actually charged, then checked again at launch with zero drift.
- Every historical order kept its original order number, payment state and tracking, and the import sent no email to any customer. The storefront runs on Horizon with no custom theme files.
- September 2026, the first full month on Shopify, brought 24 orders, the most of any September since the store opened online. Over the first 42 days orders were 3.8 times the same weeks of 2025, 35% were paid with Shop Pay, and two came from shoppers referred by ChatGPT.
- Against the store’s own strong spring on BigCommerce, orders are running about 22% ahead and revenue is level. We say that plainly below, because a case study you cannot check is just an advertisement.
The Client: Honda Race-Engine Hardware, Racing Since 1995
inlinePRO, the trading name of Inline Performance Products, is a race-engine parts maker in Springfield, Virginia, and it has been racing since 1995. Its customers are the people who build Honda and Acura engines for power: drag and road-course racers, engine builders, tuning shops and a very large number of enthusiasts doing swaps in their own garages, many of whom find the company through the Honda forums and swap groups where its parts are discussed by name. It machines its adapter plates, fuel rails, tensioners and sleeving in-house and develops its parts on its own S2000s, which matters commercially in a way that is easy to miss: when a part reaches its limit on track, the design can change the same week, and the catalog changes with it.
That catalog shape is the whole story of this migration. Here is what inlinePRO sells, by family, because every family carried a different kind of data problem.
| Product family | What it does | What made it hard to migrate |
|---|---|---|
| Head stud and main stud sets | Clamp the cylinder head on high-boost Honda engines, from the L15 to the K24 and the S2000’s F20C | Sizes, alloys and upgrade paths sold as options with their own prices |
| Connecting rods, pistons and short-block parts | Forged internals for H22, B-series and K-series builds | Bolt sizes and fitments as options; long technical titles |
| Cylinder head packages and Signature Series builds | Heads and short blocks machined to a chosen stage, often on the customer’s core | Six or seven yes/no stage checkboxes per product, each adding a price |
| Adapter plates and transmission conversions | Mate Honda engines to gearboxes they were never paired with | Generations, special-order items and kits sold with or without components |
| S2000 drivetrain and rear diff conversions | Keep the driveline alive behind modified engines | Kits with and without the differential itself |
| Turbo kits, fuel and third-party parts | Complete kits, manifolds, rails and injectors, plus parts from brands such as Garrett, Walbro and Genuine Honda | High-value items with stage pricing, alongside other makers’ catalogs |
The online history is long for a business of this size. The first order in the store’s records is from February 2018, and by the time we moved it the store held 1,419 orders worth $824,684, placed by 1,686 customers. Orders are large, averaging between about $400 and $750 depending on the year, and buyers are loyal in the way specialists are: they come back for the next car. A store like that does not need a migration that is merely fast. It needs one that is exactly right, because a single wrong price on a cylinder head package can cost more than a week of sales.
What We Found When We Looked Under BigCommerce
Before we move a store we look at it two ways, the way a buyer sees it and the way the platform’s data describes it, and compare the two. On inlinePRO that comparison started on the day the project was logged, and it produced findings that shaped everything after.
| What we checked | What we found on BigCommerce | What it meant for the move |
|---|---|---|
| Option prices from the API vs the storefront | The API disagreed with the live storefront on 295 of 409 option combinations, and omitted whole option branches | Prices would be read from the storefront, combination by combination |
| Surcharges printed on product pages | Some pages printed option surcharges that differed from what checkout actually charged | Show buyers the real price increments, taken from checkout |
| Stage options on cylinder head packages | Six or seven exclusive yes/no checkboxes per product, more option dimensions than Shopify allows | Collapse them into one Stage option a buyer can actually read |
| Category URLs | Generic paths, including a numbered product-category URL for the engine range | Clean, name-based collection handles, with every old URL redirected |
| Order exports | One full orders export later arrived empty, and some records marked Incomplete were not orders at all | Rebuild missing data from the API; exclude abandoned checkouts |
| Newsletter list | Nearly 2,000 email addresses, most of them with no customer record | A consent decision, not an import task |
Two more findings sat outside the store itself. Organic search had been sliding for a year before the move; Ahrefs’ estimate of the old site’s monthly organic visits fell from around 380 in mid-2025 to under 100 by early 2026, so the migration was never going to inherit a strong search position, and the launch would be judged on whether it held what was left. And when the domain’s DNS moved, we found the business’s email had been split between Microsoft 365 and a retired mail system at the registrar, a fault the owner had not known about. It was fixed as part of the move.
None of that is unusual. BigCommerce is a capable platform, and our own BigCommerce vs Shopify comparison is fair to it. But every long-lived store accumulates workarounds, and the export files describe the workarounds badly. The only way to move a store like this without importing its accidents is to treat the live storefront as the source of truth and the exports as a checklist.
The Pricing Trap: 295 of 409 Option Prices Wrong in the Platform’s Own API
This was the finding that changed the project. On BigCommerce, inlinePRO’s option prices are produced by a mix of option values, modifiers and rules. When you read those through BigCommerce’s APIs, you get the ingredients, not the result. When our migration technology computed the price of every purchasable combination from the API data and compared it with what the live storefront actually charged for the same combination, 295 of the 409 combinations disagreed, by anything from $20 to $1,800, and some products were missing whole branches of options, typically the “None” or base choices that the storefront offered and the API did not describe.
A migration that trusted the API would have launched with more than seven in ten configured prices wrong. Some would have been too high, which quietly loses sales; some too low, which loses money on parts that already have thin margins. Neither would have shown up in a count-based check, because the number of products and variants would have matched perfectly.
So we priced from the storefront. For every product, our tooling enumerated every combination a customer could choose, requested it from the live BigCommerce storefront, recorded the price the store charged, and wrote that price to the matching Shopify variant. The three cylinder head packages built from six or seven exclusive stage checkboxes each were restructured into a single Stage option at exactly the same prices, which is truer to how the product is sold and far easier to read on a phone. And because Shopify’s product page shows the real price of each option, the surcharges that some old pages printed incorrectly are gone.
| Check | Result |
|---|---|
| Option combinations priced | 409, each read from the live BigCommerce storefront |
| Combinations where the API disagreed with the storefront | 295, by $20 to $1,800 |
| Products restructured from stage checkboxes to one Stage option | 3, at identical prices |
| Price drift found when every combination was re-checked at launch | Zero |
| Prices that looked wrong on the old store itself | Moved as they were and put to the owner as questions, never silently changed |
That last row matters. Pricing from the storefront also surfaces prices that look wrong on the old store, and a migration is not the place to fix them by guessing. One stage of one head package was priced well below the equivalent stage on its sibling packages. It may have been a broken rule; it may have been deliberate. Either way it was the owner’s price, so it moved as it was and went to the owner as a question with the evidence attached.
At launch the whole price table was re-read from the storefront against a fresh export and compared with Shopify again. Zero drift. That check took minutes because the comparison had been built into the tooling from the start, which is the practical difference between a migration that is verified and one that is merely complete.
1,419 Orders With Their Original Numbers, 1,686 Customers With Their Consent
Order history matters more to a parts business than most. Customers reorder by referring to an old order; the shop answers fitment questions by looking up what a customer bought for which car; and the owner wants to see eight years of trading in one place. We moved every order through Shopify’s orderCreate API using RDA’s own migration app, which is what allows an imported order to keep its original order number. Each arrived with its original date, customer, line items, totals, discounts, taxes and shipping, and each carries a reference to its BigCommerce order ID so any record can be traced back to its source.
The states mattered as much as the totals. A parts business has orders in every condition, and each one had to arrive in the condition it left. Here is how the 1,405 orders in the main import broke down; the 14 placed during the build followed at launch.
| Order state on BigCommerce | Orders | How it arrived on Shopify |
|---|---|---|
| Shipped with tracking | 1,081 | Fulfilled, with the carrier and tracking number linked |
| Shipped before tracking was recorded | 119 | Fulfilled, without inventing tracking |
| Awaiting fulfillment | 84 | Unfulfilled, ready to ship |
| Cancelled | 67 | Cancelled |
| Refunded or partly refunded | 48 | Refunded to the same amount |
| Awaiting payment | 6 | Payment pending, with no phantom balances |
| Orders with a coupon | 128 | Discount carried at its true net value |
Customers came across with 1,505 addresses, 1,201 phone numbers normalized to a single format, 16 US-territory addresses repaired so Shopify would accept them, their original signup dates and 991 marketing opt-ins exactly as given. Here the right answer was sometimes to do less. A separate newsletter export contained 1,997 email addresses, of which 1,806 had no customer record at all and 43 belonged to customers whose own records said they had not opted in. Importing the list as Shopify customers would have more than doubled the customer count overnight and overridden explicit consent choices. We kept it out of the store and moved only the customers and the consent they had actually given.
The final protection was silence. Importing an order can trigger customer notifications if the import is careless, and a customer receiving an email about an order from 2019 is a good way to start a support ticket. After the import we scanned the notification timeline of every imported order: none had sent anything.
The launch used a delta sync against fresh exports, and it produced the two surprises worth passing on. The orders export arrived as an empty file, with a normal name and no error; we only knew because the shipments export referred to 14 orders we had never seen. Those orders were rebuilt from BigCommerce’s API into the same 72-column structure as the real export, so the proven importer ran unchanged. And five of the 19 new records BigCommerce listed as orders were Incomplete: abandoned checkouts, with no payment behind them. One buyer’s three failed attempts and a final successful guest checkout would have appeared as four orders for one $329.95 sale. They were excluded, all 409 prices were re-checked, and the last BigCommerce order and the first Shopify order ended up two days apart, with nothing lost in between.
Collections, Clean URLs and 320 Tested Redirects
BigCommerce categories became Shopify collections, 46 carried across directly with all 531 product placements matched, and 55 collections in all once the storefront’s engine-platform collections were added. We took the chance to fix the names in the URLs. Some of BigCommerce’s category paths were generic, including a numbered product-category path for the engine range, and on Shopify each collection now has a clean handle built from its name, so a search engine and a person can both tell what the page is about from the address.
Every old URL was then redirected to its new home: 267 products, 46 categories and seven content and brand pages, 320 redirects in all, each requested through the storefront to confirm it returned a 301 to a page that loads. Shopify’s URL redirect system normalizes paths when they are saved, so the verifier has to compare like with like; ours does. Four weeks after launch, an Ahrefs crawl found no inbound links from other sites pointing at error pages on the new store, which is the practical test of whether a redirect map held.
What we did not map is worth stating. BigCommerce’s exports contain no list of content pages, so the pages that mattered were mapped by hand and the rest are covered by watching the 404 log, where a stray old link is cheap to fix. A handful of old category URLs point into collections that are empty because every product in them had already been hidden on BigCommerce, which matches the old store’s behavior exactly; they are listed in the handover rather than papered over. That is the honest boundary of a redirect map: everything with an export behind it is covered, and everything without one is watched.
A Horizon Storefront With No Custom Theme Code
The storefront is built on Horizon, Shopify’s current flagship theme, version 4.1.3, and it contains no custom theme files at all. Everything on it, from the two-row header and the sticky add-to-cart bar to the collection pages and the home page, is done with Horizon’s own sections, blocks and settings; a file-by-file comparison shows that the only files differing from stock Horizon are its settings and template files. That was a deliberate choice for a small team. Custom code in a theme has to be carried forward by hand every time the theme moves to a new version; a store built from settings moves forward by carrying its settings across. A copy of stock Horizon sits beside it as a one-click rollback, and the old site’s fonts and logo red came across so returning customers recognized the store.
Within that discipline the store does what a technical catalog needs. Product pages use a half-and-half layout, with a large image and a row of thumbnails beside a details column wide enough for long part names, option pickers and a specification table, which is the layout we build on every Shopify store we deliver. Badges for parts that need a core or are built to order come from product data, not hand-edited text. Six automated collections group the catalog by engine platform, the way customers think about their builds: K-series, F-series and S2000, J-series, B-series, L-series and H-series. Checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay, and Shop Pay Installments is switched on, which matters when a basket regularly runs to several hundred dollars.
Two things were fixed within a week of launch, both after the owner pointed them out. Shopify’s fixed-ratio product cards were cropping 85 of the 206 photographs that were not square, so the cards were set to show the whole image; and 27 photos in which the part sat noticeably off-center were re-processed, measured rather than eyeballed, and swapped in place with the originals kept. A small thing, but on a store whose customers zoom in on machining, the photographs are the product.
One pre-launch lesson deserves its own paragraph, because it is the check most often skipped and we nearly skipped it ourselves. A migration verified entirely through the Admin API can show perfect counts while nothing is visible to a customer, because imported products and collections also have to be published to the Online Store channel, and imports do not do that by themselves. Our data checks had all passed when we found exactly that during the storefront build, more than two weeks before launch. Everything was published the same day, and the rendered storefront, not the admin, is now the final check on every migration we run.
The First Six Weeks on Shopify, in Numbers
Because every historical order came across, inlinePRO’s Shopify analytics hold more than eight years of BigCommerce trading as well as the new Shopify sales, so the comparisons below come from one source, the store’s own Shopify analytics, rather than from two platforms’ reports stitched together. The domain moved on August 20, 2026, and the first order arrived on August 21: a basket of more than $1,200, paid with Shop Pay Installments. Figures run to October 1.
| Measure | On Shopify | Comparison | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Orders, August 21 to October 1 (42 days) | 34 | 9 in the same 42 days of 2025: 3.8 times as many | Shopify analytics |
| Gross sales, same 42 days | $12,988 | $5,533 in the same days of 2025: 2.3 times as much | Shopify analytics |
| Orders in September 2026, the first full month | 24 | The most of any September since the store opened online (previous best: 20) | Shopify analytics |
| Orders, September 11 to October 1 | 23 | More than in 98.7% of all rolling three-week windows since 2019 | Shopify analytics |
| Weekly conversion rate | 0.40% in the first full week, 1.03% in the week of September 28 | Rising as search engines and returning customers caught up | Shopify analytics |
| Orders paid with Shop Pay | 12 of 34 (35%) | 15 of 34 (44%) used Shop Pay, Apple Pay or Google Pay | Shopify orders |
| Orders referred by ChatGPT | 2 | 54 visits from ChatGPT converted at 1.85% | Shopify analytics |
| Orders from returning customers | 7 | Customers whose accounts and history came across from BigCommerce | Shopify analytics |
September is normally one of this store’s quieter months, and this one was its busiest September in more than eight years online. Conversion more than doubled from the first full week to the last, which is what you expect as search engines re-index the new URLs and returning customers find their accounts; by October 1, Google had indexed about 260 of the 270 URLs in the store’s sitemap. More than a third of buyers are choosing Shop Pay, and the store took its first orders from shoppers who arrived from ChatGPT within six weeks of launch, in the year Shopify gave its merchants out-of-the-box access to ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot and other AI channels through Agentic Storefronts. None of that required a redesign campaign or an ad budget; it is what the platform does once the data underneath it is right.
Our post-migration SEO evaluation found the brand ranking first for some of its own products, such as its J-swap adapter plates, but behind its own dealers for others, because the dealers’ product pages simply say more. In the meantime one of its own kits, the S2000 rear diff conversion, has climbed from outside the top 20 to third in Google, above two of the resellers that carry it. These are small searches, a few a month each, but they are the searches its buyers make, and nothing on the site had been changed for SEO yet.
What This BigCommerce to Shopify Migration Case Study Teaches
The value of a case study is in what transfers to the next project. Almost everything above does. Here are the lessons, in the order you will meet them on your own BigCommerce to Shopify migration.
- Price from the storefront, not the API. If your products use options with their own prices, modifiers or rules, enumerate every purchasable combination and record what the live store charges. Compare that with what the API says before you trust either.
- Treat exports as a checklist. Byte-check every file before you build on it, and cross-check exports against each other. An empty export can arrive with a normal name and no error.
- Exclude Incomplete orders. On BigCommerce they are abandoned checkouts, not sales. Import them and your history and your analytics are both wrong.
- Keep the order numbers and the states. Import orders through the Admin API with their original names, dates, payment and fulfillment states and tracking, and store the source order ID on each one.
- Prove nothing was sent. After importing orders, scan their notification timelines. Silence is a result you can check, so check it.
- Respect consent over counts. A newsletter list is not a customer list. Move customers with the consent they gave, and make the list a separate decision.
- Ask, do not fix. Storefront pricing will expose prices that look wrong on the old store. Move them as they are and put them to the owner as questions with evidence.
- Redirect what has an export, watch what does not. Map every product and category URL, test each one through the storefront, and watch the 404 log for pages the exports never listed.
- Publish, then check the rendered store. Imports do not publish products or collections to the Online Store channel. The admin will look perfect while the storefront is empty.
- Prefer settings to code. A Horizon store built from settings carries forward to the next theme version without anyone rewriting code.
If your store is on BigCommerce, our BigCommerce to Shopify migration guide turns these lessons into a checklist, and the BigCommerce vs Shopify comparison covers the platform decision itself.
A Quick Overview of Ruby Digital Agency (and Why We Care)
For readers meeting us for the first time: Ruby Digital Agency is a Shopify Plus Partner. We move brands onto Shopify and Shopify Plus from other platforms, we build new Shopify stores from the ground up, and we make both pay for themselves. Our migration clients arrive from BigCommerce, WooCommerce, Magento and Adobe Commerce, OpenCart, Shift4Shop, PrestaShop, Weebly and Square Online, Wix, and custom PHP builds. Smaller, owner-run stores are usually live in three to four weeks; a standard migration for a mid-market brand doing roughly $2M to $20M a year runs 4 to 8 weeks; and an enterprise replatform to Shopify Plus, typically from Magento, Adobe Commerce or a custom stack, runs six to eight weeks. Any of these can be compressed when a deadline is urgent. All of them are delivered with zero downtime and with SEO equity preserved through a complete, tested 301 redirect map, and in all of them the specialists who architect the project are the ones who deliver it. Because we build in free Shopify development stores, you pay Shopify nothing until the day you go live.
| Service | Who it is for | Typical timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Standard Shopify Migration | Mid-market brands, $2M–$20M/yr | 4–8 weeks |
| Shopify Plus Replatforming | Enterprise brands, $20M+/yr, from Magento, Adobe Commerce or custom builds | 6–8 weeks |
| Shopify Store Builds | New brands and rebuilds on Horizon, with no custom code where settings will do | Scoped per project |
| Multi-Store and Subscription Integration | B2B wholesale, subscriptions, multi-brand architectures | Scoped per project |
| Ecommerce Website Audits | Any platform: Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Magento, custom | Fixed-scope engagement |
| SEO and AEO | Brands that need to be found in Google and cited by AI assistants | Ongoing |
| Shopify POS Implementation | Retailers uniting stores and online | Scoped per project |
Some of the work is public. Midwood Guitar Studio also came from BigCommerce, with Shopify POS for its shop; SoSlanty moved from Weebly with its Google Shopping history intact; Tempus Takumi, an independent watch boutique in New York, is a Shopify store we built from the catalog up; D.T. Medical Devices came from WooCommerce in Germany; Earache Records and The Gadget Guys from OpenCart. The full list is on our case studies page, and in July we published what happened when we let an AI agent run a Shopify Plus migration, with the data.
Why does a specialist parts maker get the same treatment as a Plus replatform? Because the failure modes are identical and the owner has less margin for them. A mispriced option on a cylinder head package hurts a small manufacturer more than it hurts a brand with a pricing team. The work that ran inlinePRO’s migration, the storefront price harvest, the order import, the consent handling, the redirect tests and the reconciliation behind all of them, was produced and executed by our in-house AI-driven migration technology and checked by a person who is accountable for every result. That is how all our work is done now, and it is why the data for a store with eight years of history could be moved and verified in two days.
A Ten-Step Plan for Your Own BigCommerce to Shopify Migration
If you run a BigCommerce store, this is the order we would follow, whether you work with us, with another agency, or on your own. Each step exists because skipping it would have cost inlinePRO something.
- Export everything and byte-check it. Products, customers, orders with no date filter, shipments and the newsletter list. Open every file, and cross-check them against each other.
- Harvest your real prices. For every product with priced options, enumerate each combination and record what the live storefront charges. Keep that table; it is the source of truth for the whole project.
- Decide your option model. Collapse checkbox stacks into options a buyer can read, within Shopify’s limits, and agree the structure with whoever answers the phone.
- Open a free Shopify development store through a partner. Build there. You should pay Shopify nothing until the day you switch.
- Import products, then customers, then orders. Orders through the Admin API with their original numbers, dates, states and tracking; customers with the consent they gave; abandoned checkouts left behind.
- Reconcile against the source, field by field. Prices per combination, totals and states per order, consent per customer. Matching counts prove nothing.
- Build the storefront on Horizon with settings first. Use custom code only where settings genuinely cannot do the job.
- Map and test every redirect. Product, category and content URLs, each requested through the storefront and confirmed as a 301 to a page that loads.
- Publish to the Online Store and test like a customer. Buy something cheap and something expensive, with Shop Pay and with a card, on a phone.
- Launch with a delta sync and watch for 30 days. Fresh exports, import what was placed during the build, re-check prices, move DNS, then read the 404 log and Search Console weekly. Close BigCommerce last.
Running a store on BigCommerce?
We will look at your actual exports and your live storefront before we quote anything, and tell you plainly what will move, what will not, and how long it will take. Book a migration strategy call, or start with our BigCommerce to Shopify migration guide.
What Happens If You Do Nothing
Nothing dramatic, which is the problem. A BigCommerce store with years of option rules keeps working, and the rules keep accumulating. Each new product is priced by analogy with the last one, each special case adds a modifier, and the distance between what the configuration says and what the storefront charges keeps growing where nobody is looking. inlinePRO’s store was taking orders perfectly well; it was also carrying hundreds of combinations whose prices only the storefront itself could explain, product pages that printed surcharges checkout did not charge, and an email setup that was quietly splitting incoming mail between two systems.
The other cost is opportunity. On Shopify, Shop Pay was carrying more than a third of inlinePRO’s orders within six weeks, Shop Pay Installments was available on every large basket from the very first order, and shoppers arriving from ChatGPT were already buying, in a year when Shopify gave its merchants out-of-the-box access to the major AI shopping channels. Whatever platform you are on, ask how much of that you can do today without adding another tool.
And the move itself gets harder the longer you wait, because there is more history to protect. Eight years of orders moved cleanly here because the data was examined before it was imported. Twelve years would have moved too, but with more exceptions to explain. If you are not ready to move, do the first two steps of the plan anyway: export everything and harvest your real prices. It costs a day, and it tells you more about your store than any migration quote.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a BigCommerce to Shopify migration take?
inlinePRO took 26 days from kickoff to go-live, and the data itself, 267 products, 1,686 customers and 1,419 orders, was imported and verified in the first two days. The rest of the time went on the storefront, testing and a delta sync before launch. Most smaller BigCommerce stores are live in three to four weeks and mid-market stores in four to eight.
Can I keep my BigCommerce order numbers on Shopify?
Yes. Orders imported through the Shopify Admin API orderCreate mutation can keep their original order names, dates, totals, payment states and fulfillment with tracking. inlinePRO kept all 1,419 original order numbers, and each order also stores its BigCommerce order ID so it can be traced to the source. New orders on Shopify continue from a later number, so there is no clash.
Do BigCommerce option prices transfer correctly to Shopify?
Not reliably. On inlinePRO, prices computed from the BigCommerce API disagreed with the live storefront on 295 of 409 option combinations, by 20 to 1,800 dollars, and some option branches were missing from the API entirely. The safe method is to enumerate every combination, record the price the live storefront charges, use that as the source of truth, and re-check it at launch.
Will customers get emails when old orders are imported into Shopify?
They should not, and you can prove it. Import orders with customer notifications turned off, then scan the timeline of every imported order for sent notifications. On inlinePRO the scan found none across all 1,419 orders, so no customer heard about an old order from the new store.
Should I import BigCommerce Incomplete orders?
No. Orders with the Incomplete status in BigCommerce are abandoned checkouts with no payment behind them. On inlinePRO, 5 of 19 new records at the final sync were Incomplete, and one sale would have appeared as four orders. Exclude them and import only orders that were actually placed, whether paid, refunded or cancelled.
Will I lose SEO rankings moving from BigCommerce to Shopify?
Not if every old URL redirects to its new page and you watch the results. inlinePRO launched with 320 redirects, every product, category and key content URL tested through the storefront as a 301 to a live page, and four weeks later a crawl found no inbound links pointing at error pages. Rankings usually wobble for a few weeks while search engines re-index, then settle.
Can a Shopify store sell to shoppers who find it through ChatGPT?
Yes. In March 2026 Shopify launched Agentic Storefronts, which give merchants out of the box access to AI channels such as ChatGPT, Microsoft Copilot, AI Mode in Google Search and the Gemini app, managed from the Shopify admin, with orders attributed to the channel they came from. inlinePRO recorded two orders from shoppers referred by ChatGPT within six weeks of launch.
Final Thoughts
A parts business lives or dies on two things a migration can quietly break: the price of the exact configuration a customer chooses, and the history that lets it answer the question “what did I buy for this car last time?” On inlinePRO both came across intact, and the price table is now more trustworthy than it was on the old platform, because every price in it was read from what customers were actually being charged, and the questionable ones went to the owner instead of being guessed.
What I would tell a BigCommerce merchant in one sentence is this: your exports describe your store, but your storefront is your store, so build the migration on the storefront. Do that, keep your order numbers, respect your customers’ consent, and test every redirect, and the move stops being a risk and becomes the easiest growth decision you make this year.
inlinePRO is live, taking orders, with more than eight years of history intact and its busiest September since it started selling online. If you are building a Honda this winter, the head studs are the place to start.
Planning a Move to Shopify or Shopify Plus?
We plan the strategy, run the heavy lifting with our own AI-driven migration technology, verify every record against your source data before go-live, and protect the search history your store has earned. Book a migration strategy call and we will map your move.
Related Reading
- BigCommerce to Shopify Migration Guide
- BigCommerce vs Shopify: An Honest Comparison
- Shopify Watch Store Case Study: Tempus Takumi
- Weebly to Shopify Migration Case Study: SoSlanty
- Case Study: Midwood Guitar Studio from BigCommerce to Shopify with POS
- We Let an AI Agent Run a Shopify Plus Migration — Here’s the Data
- Post-Migration SEO Evaluation
- All Ruby Digital Agency Case Studies
- More Shopify Guides on Our Blog
Lance Allison
Founder & CEO, Ruby Digital Agency
Lance Allison is a Shopify Plus Partner and eCommerce migration specialist based in Salt Lake City, Utah. He has helped hundreds of merchants move to Shopify and Shopify Plus, and specializes in complex, data-heavy platform migrations, including BigCommerce stores whose option pricing, order history and search rankings all have to survive the move intact.